Designing a Metric to Detect Big Balls of Mud

Alexander von Zitzewitz Leave a comment

Almost everyone who worked in software development for a while has come in contact with the dreaded big ball of mud (BBoM). If you are not familiar with the term, it describes software systems that have lost their architectural cohesion and suffer from extreme coupling and large cyclic dependency groups. That makes it much harder to do any changes on those systems, because everything is literally connected to everything else. Therefor it requires developers spending almost all their time trying to understand code before they can risk doing changes. And even then, the chance of regression bugs stay pretty high. If a system reaches this state, doing changes becomes so expensive, that rewriting the system from scratch might be cheaper than maintaining the old system. Unfortunately, very often it is not possible to rewrite the system, because the users can’t wait for years for a system replacement. This puts many development organization in a very uncomfortable place.

A big ball of mud visualized by Sonargraph

Read More

Changes to the Sonargraph Dashboard

Alexander von Zitzewitz Leave a comment

The Sonargraph dashboard was designed to give the user a quick overview about several important aspects of software quality. The most important aspects in our opinion are “Architecture” and “Structure”, which are displayed at the top of the dashboard. After some internal discussions we decided that we could improve the metrics in the “Structure” box. Those changes will be rolled out with Sonargraph version 15.2.0, which is expected to be released this week.

Read More

Using Sonargraph-Enterprise to Track Key Quality Metrics

Alexander von Zitzewitz Leave a comment

Sonargraph-Enterprise is designed to allow stake-holders to track important software quality metrics over time. The idea is that this would enable the early detection of harmful trends so that issues can be fixed while they are still easy to fix. The metrics displayed by Sonargraph-Enterprise can be fully customized by the user. However, in this article I will explain the “default” profile that comes with a set of preselected metrics that cover important aspects of code health and quality.

Read More

Setting up Sonargraph on your Project

Alexander von Zitzewitz Leave a comment

Over the years we implemented many different methods to set up Sonargraph for your project. Some of them are now quite outdated and are only kept in the tool for compatibility reasons. This article is meant to help you with your initial setup and chose the most effective method for your particular circumstances. There is one section for each language supported by Sonargraph.

General Recommendations

Sonargraph maintains a folder for each software system, that contains a description of your project, the locations of source folders (and class folders for Java), your architecture model and all other parts of a Sonargraph quality model. We call this folder the Sonargraph system folder. It only contains text files (mostly XML) and should ideally be placed in the root directory of your VCS (version control system) repository. You also should add this folder to your VCS, since the Sonargraph model will evolve together with your software system. This will allow you to share one Sonargraph model with all the developers working on your project.

Each Sonargraph software system contains at least one module. Modules usually correspond to the modules or sub-projects in your IDE.

How to initially create this folder for your project is the subject of this article. The folder should have the name of your software system and always ends with ‘.sonargraph’.

Read More

Using ccspy for C/C++ Project Setup

Alexander von Zitzewitz Leave a comment

Analyzing C/C++ projects with Sonargraph is always a bit more difficult due to the huge variety of different compilers and environments. We recently added a new import wizard that should simplify the process.

For a successful analysis of a C/C++ projects Sonargraph must be able to emulate the compiler you are using and also needs to know which source files are part of the project and the compiler options used for each source file, mostly the -I options for include directories and the -D options which influence conditional compilation.

The first part is solved by a so called “compiler definition”. Sonargraph comes with predefined compiler definitions depending on your platform. If your compiler is not among them you can always create a new compiler definition (menu File / New / Configuration). You can also manage your compiler definitions in the Sonargraph preferences. The main job of a compiler definition is to define the location of implicit include directories (for standard headers like stdio.h) and to define all predefined macros of your compiler platform.

Read More

Discovering Software Rot

Ingmar Kellner Leave a comment

Since I have seen some announcements about talks targeting the German Corona Warn App, I was interested to see, what kind of information I could extract with Sonargraph.

The project is still pretty young, but maybe, there is already some structural erosion happening? (Spoiler: There is!)

This blog post is about the setup of the analysis-pipeline consisting of Sonargraph-Build and Sonargraph-Enterprise that allowed me to analyse 24 versions (1.4.0 to 2.9.0) of the CWA-Server project and investigate metric trends.

The execution is implemented in Java and published as a new repo “Sonargraph-Build Batch“. If anybody is interested in analyzing past versions of a project with Sonargraph, “Sonargraph-Build Batch” can serve as a starting point.

Read More

Recently Added Usability Improvements

Ingmar Kellner Leave a comment

During the last months we released a couple of major features in Sonargraph that allowed easier interaction like the ‘Architectural View’ and improved the interpretation of results like the ‘System Diff’, ‘Quality Gates’ or ‘Issue Ranking’.  We have described the power of these features in individual blog posts.

Some implemented improvements are less obvious, but nevertheless can have a big impact while working with Sonargraph.

This blog post highlights four hidden gems that the casual Sonargraph user might not know about:

  1. Improved issue to resolution matching
  2. Filtering in tables
  3. Visualizing cycle croups in Exploration view
  4. Passing selection between Sonargraph and Eclipse IDE
Read More

Identify the Most Relevant Issues to Fix

Ingmar Kellner Leave a comment

Using Sonargraph to analyse a large code base usually reveals a lot of issues. The “System Diff” helps to keep the quality level by highlighting new and worsened issues as described in a previous blog post. But up to now there has been no recommendation about which of the already existing issues should be fixed first.
The new “Ranking” view available in Sonargraph 11.5 does exactly that and this blog post describes how it works.

Read More